State Adjusting Services

Slab leak insurance claims in Illinois

A water line or a drain pipe breaks under the concrete: the basement floor most Illinois houses sit on, or the slab of a ranch, a townhouse or a store. Nobody sees it until the floor is warm, the meter keeps turning or water comes up through a crack. We are licensed Illinois public adjusters, and we prepare and present this claim for the owner.

Under the floor, cut openA drawing, not to scale. The numbers match the list below it.
Concrete slab Gravel base Water supply line Drain line Soil 6 1 2 3 4 5 Water supply line Drain line Concrete slab Gravel base Soil 1 2 3 4 5 6
  1. 1
    Flooring, baseboards, cabinets PaidWater damage to the building from a plumbing system on the premises.
  2. 2
    Breaking and re-pouring the slab PaidThe tear-out sentence, when opening the floor is needed to repair the pipe.
  3. 3
    The cracked length of pipe YoursThe form does not pay for the system the water escaped from.
  4. 4
    Soil the water washed out DependsEarth movement and settling exclusions are where carriers push back.
  5. 5
    A broken drain under the floor DependsWater leaking out of a drain is plumbing; sewage backing up through it is a backup claim.
  6. 6
    Your belongings and a place to stay PaidPersonal property, and loss of use if the home cannot be lived in during the work.

"Water below the surface of the ground," and the sentence that switches it off

A leak under the slab soaks the gravel and the soil before it reaches the floor. That is why the first letter on a slab leak claim often quotes the water exclusion. The standard Homeowners 3 form answers that letter itself. We read it in edition HO 00 03 05 11, from the copy the Maine Bureau of Insurance publishes. Your own carrier may use another edition or its own wording, so we always check your policy first.

Section I, Exclusion A.3.c
"Water below the surface of the ground, including water which exerts pressure on, or seeps, leaks or flows through a building, sidewalk, driveway, patio, foundation, swimming pool or other structure"

Written for ground water: a high water table pushing up through a basement floor.

Coverage A and B, after Exception To c.(6)
"Section I, Exclusion A.3. Water, Paragraphs a. and c. that apply to surface water and water below the surface of the ground do not apply to loss by water covered under c.(5) and (6) above."

c.(6) is the exception that gives back water from a plumbing system on the residence premises.

So on this form, water that came out of your own supply line or drain under the floor is not "ground water" just because it passed through the ground. The question that decides the claim is where the water came from. If it was a pipe that burst in the cold, our burst pipe damage page covers the freezing conditions that apply to that case.

From finding the leak to the new floor: who pays each part of the job

The work happens in this order, and the bills come in the same order. The middle column is how the ISO wording treats each step. The right column is the proof we ask you to keep, because each line is argued on its own.

Step of the jobHow the form treats itKeep this
Leak detection: pressure test, listening gear, camera in the drainNot named. We claim it as part of the cost to reach the system, and the carrier decides it on the invoice.The detection report with the location marked on a floor sketch
Cutting and removing flooring and concrete over the leakPaid when needed to repair the system: the tear-out sentence.Photos before the saw touches the floor, then of the open trench
Replacing the broken length of pipeNot paid. Loss to the system the water escaped from is left out.The removed section of pipe, bagged and labeled
A new line rerouted through walls or the ceiling insteadPlumbing work, so yours. Ask the carrier in writing, before the work, how it will treat the walls opened for the new route.The plumber's two prices: repair under the slab and reroute
Backfill, gravel, vapor barrier and new concretePaid as replacing the part of the building torn out.The concrete contractor's invoice with square footage
Flooring, baseboard, lower drywall, cabinets the water reachedPaid as water damage to the dwelling.Moisture readings room by room from the drying company
Mold found under the floor coveringPaid if hidden beneath the floors and caused by the plumbing leak; many policies add a dollar cap by endorsement.The mold report and where it was found
Hotel or rent while the house has no water or no floorPaid under loss of use when the home is not fit to live in.Receipts, and the dates the water was off

Mold after a leak has its own limits and its own fights; our mold damage claims page walks through them.

When the water moves the soil under the floor

A leak that runs under a slab can wash out the gravel and soil, and the concrete or the footings then drop or crack. The ISO form excludes settling and cracking of foundations and floors, and it excludes earth movement, "including earth sinking, rising or shifting," however it is caused. Carriers reach for those words when the soil is part of the damage.

The water damage that came out of the pipe is still given back by the plumbing exception, unless another exclusion takes it out. The fight is usually over the structural part: footings, a sunken section of floor, cracks in the walls above. The Illinois case on the right shows how much the wording and the named cause decide.

Two lessons we take from it. First, in 1993 that policy's water exclusion had no sentence giving back water from your own plumbing, which the 2011 ISO edition now has. Second, the engineers tied the broken pipes to pressure from the city sewer system, so the claim landed on the $1,000 backup endorsement. A cause named on the file early is hard to change later. Our article on foundation cracks and the earth movement exclusion goes further into that part.

Indiana Insurance Co. v. Liaskos297 Ill. App. 3d 569, Illinois Appellate Court, First District, decided June 24, 1998. Read the opinion
  1. A home in Calumet City. The owner wakes to a loud exploding noise. The basement floor slab has cracked and pushed up.
  2. Same nightWater fills the basement almost to the floor joists. Cracks show on first-floor walls and the outside brick, and a crater opens in the yard.
  3. The engineersBoth sides agree water pressure below the ground caused the loss. The owner's engineer says pressure in the city sewer system overstressed the plumbing and the water undermined footings.
  4. The carrierPays $1,000 under the sewer and drain backup endorsement and asks the court to rule the rest excluded.
  5. The rulingNo "collapse" under the exception to the water exclusion: the house had not fallen down or lost its character. Judgment for the carrier, affirmed.

What the plumber's report should say before the floor is closed

On a slab leak the plumber is the first expert on the file, and often the only one who sees the broken pipe in place. A report that says "slab leak repaired" proves almost nothing. One that names the pipe, the break and the cause answers the two questions every carrier asks: was it sudden, and was it your plumbing or the ground.

Ask for it in writing on the day of the repair, with photos of the open trench. Keep the removed piece of pipe; a split along its length looks different from a pinhole eaten through by corrosion, and the carrier may want its own expert to look at it. If the break is in a sewer line outside the house rather than under the floor, our article on a broken sewer line insurance claim covers that version.

Leak repair reportExample, made-up details
Where
Under the kitchen floor, 4 ft from the east wall
Pipe
3/4 in. copper, hot water supply
Depth
10 in. below top of slab
The break
Split 2 in. long at a bend, edges clean
Water found
Gravel saturated about 6 ft around the break
Found how
Meter moving with all fixtures off; pressure test; acoustic
Done
Section cut out and replaced; old piece given to owner
An illustration of the details that matter, not a real job.

Pipes and footings under the floor are left out of the 80% count

Replacement cost on the ISO form depends on carrying insurance of at least 80% of the full cost to rebuild the house. Owners facing a large slab repair often ask whether they were underinsured. When that 80% figure is worked out, the form says not to include excavations, footings and foundations below the lowest basement floor, supports below ground with no basement, and underground flues, pipes, wiring and drains.

The proportions are drawn for clarity, not measured from a real house.Source: HO 00 03 05 11, Section I Conditions, Loss Settlement

The repair itself is still paid as a building loss. The form only removes those parts from the test of whether your limit was high enough. Until the work is done, the carrier pays actual cash value and holds back the rest, which is why the dates of the repair matter.

Send us the slab leak and the carrier's letter

The first review costs nothing. Tell us where the pipe broke and what the carrier has said so far, and we read your policy against it. Our office is in Lincolnshire and we take calls seven days a week: Monday through Friday 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM, Saturday and Sunday 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM. Owners have rated us 4.9 from 33 Google reviews; read them on our reviews page.

  • The address and the day the leak was found
  • The plumber's report and photos of the open floor
  • Your full policy, declarations page and endorsements
  • Any letter, estimate or denial from the carrier

Licensing rules set by the State

Under the rules of the Illinois Department of Insurance, a public adjuster must hold an Illinois license and use a written contract approved by the Director. Call the Department at (866) 445-5364 to check a license before you sign.

Four fields is all we need

Prefer to write more? Use the full form. We use your details only to review your claim.

Questions owners ask about a leak under the slab

  • Do you handle slab leak claims in Illinois?

    Yes. We represent homeowners and owners of rental and commercial buildings across Illinois when a water line or drain breaks under a concrete floor or basement slab.

  • Does homeowners insurance pay to break up the slab to reach the leak?

    On the ISO Homeowners 3 form, yes, when opening the floor is needed to repair the plumbing. The form pays to tear out and replace that part of the building, and to repair the water damage, but not to fix the pipe itself.

  • My carrier says water under the ground is excluded. Is that right for a slab leak?

    Not on the 2011 ISO form. It says the surface water and below-ground water exclusions do not apply to water covered under the plumbing exception, so water from your own pipe under the floor is judged as plumbing, not ground water.

  • Is the soil the leak washed away covered?

    That is the hard part. The form excludes settling, cracking and earth movement, so carriers often pay the water damage and refuse the structural repair. The plumber's and engineer's reports on what caused what decide that line.

  • What does a slab leak claim cost me?

    Nothing at the start. Our fee is a percentage of what the carrier pays on this claim, written into the contract you sign with us, and if the carrier pays nothing you owe us nothing.